Claims
Please call us as soon as possible at (740) 286-5031 to report any claims. For your convenience, you can report claims directly to the following carriers.
Cincinnati Insurance Company (877) 242-2544
Erie Insurance (800) 367-3743
Western Reserve (800) 362-0426
Grange Insurance (800) 445-3030
Progressive Insurance (800) 274-4499
Tuscarora Wayne (800) 669-4002
Travelers Insurance (800) 252-4633
Westfield Insurance Company (866) 937-2663
Billing
For questions regarding your bill, please call Carlisle Insurance, or any of the company direct numbers listed below.
Cincinnati Insurance Direct Bill (800) 364-3400
Erie Insurance (800) 387-1492
Western Reserve Group (800) 362-0426
Grange Insurance (800) 425-1100
Progressive Insurance (800) 876-5581
Tuscarora Wayne (800) 669-4002
Travelers Insurance (800) 550-7716
Westfield Insurance (800) 552-9134